On July 3rd, three of us made the trip to Union Springs, on the east side of Cayuga Lake, north of Aurora. This was our collective second visit to Wheelhouse Restaurant on Hibiscus Harbor. This best-kept secret of a hideaway is well worth the drive!
This is a seasonal business, so make sure to call before heading out. It's nestled in a marina, just off of the lake, which on Saturday, was riddled with whitecaps. Our cove, unexpectedly tucked in a mere paddle from the lake proper, was serene. Accessible by boat and car, Wheelhouse is both charming and unassuming. But there is a certain elegant ambiance in the dining room and a casual, comfortable feel to the tavern side. That said, both times we've gone, we have opted for seating on the deck since we love sitting by the water and, let's face it, outdoor lakeside dining options are limited by weather, season, and locations in the Finger Lakes.
On this visit, we opted to share most of the items that we ordered: A bottle of Treleaven Chardonnay (pricey), Cajun bleu-burger, fish tacos and medium chicken wings. The burger came with fries, but it was extra to add them to the tacos, which we did. The staff were charming. It did take quite a while to get served once we ordered, so don't plan to rush this dining experience. In retrospect, we should have asked for the wings as an appetizer.
As I reflect, I think the burgers we ordered on our first visit in 2019 were more sumptuous than Saturday's editions, and the servings of fries more generous. However, we really enjoyed the burger and really, how many fries can you eat anyway?! The fish tacos were simply sublime - lightly breaded and fried with just a tad too much iceberg lettuce. But there was plenty to go around - in fact, the large serving of three tacos was too much for our party of three and our friend took home the third. The fried wings were good. Not breaded, thank goodness! We opted for medium, which was a compromise for all of us: Our friend dislikes spicy food and the two of us prefer hot Buffalo-style wings. But honestly, the medium wings just didn't have the kick any of us would have preferred. Still the serving included 10 large wings and we took 6 home. We added hot sauce to the leftovers and they were excellent!
Wheelhouse Restaurant is about a 45 minute drive north from Ithaca, NY. Be sure to put this little hole in the wall, gem of a place on your next trip itinerary!
(C. Cat, 07/05/21 @ 10:36am)